8 Chapter 8 Solutions to Problems – Benzene and Aromaticity

Chapter 8 – Benzene and Aromaticity

Solutions to Problems

8.1 image

The electronic descriptions of pyridine and benzene are very similar. The pyridine ring is formed by the σ overlap of carbon and nitrogen sp2 orbitals. In addition, six p orbitals, perpendicular to the plane of the ring, hold six electrons. These six p orbitals form six π molecular orbitals that allow electrons to be delocalized over the π system of the pyridine ring. The lone pair of nitrogen electrons occupies an sp2 orbital that lies in the plane of the ring.

 

8.2 An ortho disubstituted benzene has two substituents in a 1,2 relationship. A meta disubstituted benzene has two substituents in a 1,3 relationship. A para disubstituted benzene has two substituents in a 1,4 relationship.
(a) image (b) image (c) image

 

8.3 Remember to give the lowest possible numbers to substituents on trisubstituted rings.
(a) image (b) image (c) image
(d) image (e) image (f) image

 

8.4 (a) image (b) image (c) image
(d) image

 

8.5  

image

 

8.6  

image

Chlorination at either position “a” of o-xylene yields product A, and chlorination at either position “b” yields product B.

image

Three products might be expected to form on chlorination of m–xylene.

image

Only one product results from chlorination of p–xylene because all sites are equivalent.

 

8.7 To identify the carboxylic acid chloride used in the Friedel–Crafts acylation of benzene, break the bond between benzene and the ketone carbon and replace it with a –Cl.

(a)

image

(b)

image

 

8.8 Use Figure 8.11 to find the activating and deactivating effects of groups.

Most Reactive ———————> Least Reactive

(a) Phenol > toluene > benzene > nitrobenzene
(b) Phenol > benzene > chlorobenzene > benzoic acid
(c) Aniline > benzene > bromobenzene > benzaldehyde

 

8.9 Refer to Figure 8.11 in the text for the directing effects of substituents. You should memorize the effects of the most important groups. As in Worked Example 8.1, identify the directing effect of the substituent, and draw the product.

(a)

image

Even though bromine is a deactivator, it is an ortho-para director.

(b)

image

The –NO2 group is a meta-director.

(c)

image

(d)

image

No catalyst is necessary because aniline is highly activating.

 

8.10 (Trifluoromethyl) benzene is less reactive toward electrophilic substitution than toluene. The electronegativity of the three fluorine atoms causes the trifluoromethyl group to be electron-withdrawing and deactivating toward electrophilic substitution. The electrostatic potential map shows that the aromatic ring of (trifluoromethyl) benzene is more electron-poor, and thus less reactive, than the ring of toluene (red).

 

8.11  

image

For acetanilide, resonance delocalization of the nitrogen lone pair electrons to the aromatic ring is less favored because the positive charge on nitrogen is next to the positively polarized carbonyl group. Resonance delocalization to the carbonyl oxygen is favored because of the electronegativity of oxygen. Since the nitrogen lone pair electrons are less available to the ring than in aniline, the reactivity of the ring toward electrophilic substitution is decreased, and acetanilide is less reactive than aniline toward electrophilic substitution.

 

8.12  

image

The circled resonance forms are unfavorable, because they place two positive charges adjacent to each other. The intermediate from meta attack is thus favored.

 

8.13 Oxidation takes place at the benzylic position.

(a)

image

(b)

image

Treatment with KMnO4 oxidizes the methyl group but leaves the tert-butyl group untouched.

 

Additional Problems

Visualizing Chemistry

8.14 (a) image (b) image

 

8.15 Three resonance forms for the carbocation of the formula C13H9 are shown below, and more can be drawn. These forms show that the positive charge of the carbocation can be stabilized in the same way as an allylic or benzylic carbocation is stabilized – by overlap with the neighboring π electrons of the ring system.

image

 

8.16 image

Molecules with dipole moments are polar because electron density is drawn from one part of the molecule to another. In azulene, for example, electron density is drawn from the seven-membered ring to the five-membered ring, satisfying Hückel’s rule for both rings and producing a dipole moment. The five-membered ring resembles the cyclopentadienyl anion in having six π electrons, while the seven-membered ring resembles the cycloheptatrienyl cation. The electrostatic potential map shows that the five-membered ring is more electron-rich (red) than the seven-membered ring.

 

8.17  

(a) The methoxyl group is an ortho–para director.

image

(b) Both functional groups direct substituents to the same position.

image

 

8.18  

image

 

8.19 Imagine two routes for synthesis of m-nitrotoluene:

(1) Alkylation of benzene, followed by nitration, doesn’t succeed because an alkyl group is an o,p-director.
(2) Nitration of benzene, followed by alkylation, doesn’t succeed because nitrobenzene is unreactive to Friedel–Crafts alkylation.

Thus, it isn’t possible to synthesize m-nitrotoluene by any route that we have studied in this chapter.

 

Naming Aromatic Compounds

8.20 (a) image (b) image (c) image
(d) image (e) image (f) image

 

8.21 (a) image (b) image (c) image
(d) image (e) image (f) image

 

8.22 (a) image
(b) image
(c) image

 

8.23 All aromatic compounds of formula C7H7Cl have one ring and three double bonds.

image

 

8.24

Six of these compounds are illustrated and named in Problem 8.22 (b).The other eight are:

image

 

Structures of Organic Compounds

8.25 All compounds in this problem have four double bonds and/or rings and must be substituted benzenes, if they are to be aromatic. They may be substituted by methyl, ethyl, propyl, or butyl groups.
(a) image
(b) image
(c) image
(d) image

 

8.26 image

The bond between carbons 1 and 2 is represented as a double bond in two of the three resonance structures, but the bond between carbons 2 and 3 is represented as a double bond in only one resonance structure. The C1–C2 bond thus has more double-bond character in the resonance hybrid, and it is shorter than the C2–C3 bond. The C3–C4, C5–C6, and C7–C8 bonds also have more double-bond character than the remaining bonds.

 

8.27 image

 

8.28-8.29 image

The circled bond is represented as a double bond in four of the five resonance forms of phenanthrene. This bond has more double-bond character and thus is shorter than the other carbon–carbon bonds of phenanthrene.

 

8.30 image

Indole, like naphthalene, has ten π electrons in two rings and is aromatic. Two π electrons come from the nitrogen atom.

 

8.31 The 1,2,4-triazole ring is aromatic because it has 6 π electrons in a cyclic, conjugated system.

image

 

Mechanisms of Electrophilic Substitutions

8.32  

image

ICl can be represented as Iδ+ — Clδ− because chlorine is a more electronegative element than iodine. Iodine can act as an electrophile in electrophilic aromatic substitution reactions.

 

8.33 When an electrophile reacts with an aromatic ring bearing a (CH3)3N+– group:

image

The N,N,N-trimethylammonium group has no electron-withdrawing resonance effect because it has no vacant p orbitals to overlap with the π orbital system of the aromatic ring. The (CH3)3N+– group is inductively deactivating, however, because it is positively charged. It is meta-directing because the cationic intermediate resulting from meta attack is somewhat more stable than those resulting from ortho or para attack.

 

8.34  

image

Resonance structures show that bromination occurs in the ortho and para positions of the rings. The positively charged intermediate formed from ortho or para attack can be stabilized by resonance contributions from the second ring of biphenyl, but this stabilization is not possible for meta attack.

 

8.35  

image

Protonation of the double bond at carbon 2 of 1-phenylpropene leads to an intermediate that can be stabilized by resonance involving the benzene ring.

 

8.36  

image

Step 1: Formation of primary carbocation.

Step 2: Rearrangement to a secondary carbocation.

Step 3: Attack of ring π electrons on the carbocation.

Step 4: Loss of H+.

This reaction takes place despite the fact that an electron-withdrawing group is attached to the ring. Apparently, the cyclization reaction is strongly favored.

 

8.37  

image

Step 1: SN2 displacement takes place when the negatively charged oxygen of dimethyl sulfoxide attacks the benzylic carbon of benzyl bromide, displacing Br.

Step 2: Base removes a benzylic proton, and dimethyl sulfide is eliminated in an E2 reaction.

 

Reactivity and Orientation of Electrophilic Substitutions

8.38  

image

 

8.39  

(a)

image

(b)

image

(c)

image

(d)

image

(e)

image

(f)

image

Only methoxybenzene reacts faster than benzene (See Figure 8.11).

 

8.40 Most reactive ———–> Least reactive

(a) Benzene > Chlorobenzene > o-Dichlorobenzene
(b) Phenol > Nitrobenzene > p-Bromonitrobenzene
(c) o-Xylene > Fluorobenzene > Benzaldehyde
(d) p-Methoxybenzonitrile > p-Methylbenzonitrile > Benzonitrile

 

8.41  

(a)

image

(b)

image

Both groups direct substitution to the same position.

(c)

image

(d)

image

(e)

image

(f)

image

(g)

image

(h)

image

Alkylation occurs in the indicated position because the methyl group is more activating than bromine, and because substitution rarely takes place between two groups.

 

8.42 Most reactive ——–> Least reactive

Phenol > Toluene > p-Bromotoluene > Bromobenzene

Aniline and nitrobenzene don’t undergo Friedel–Crafts alkylations.

 

8.43  

(a)

image

Aqueous KMnO4 oxidizes alkyl side chains to benzoic acids.

 

8.44  

(a)

image

(b)

image

(c)

image

(d)

image

 

Organic Synthesis

8.45  

(a)

image

(b)

image

The reactions in (b) can be performed in either order.

(c)

image

 

8.46 When synthesizing substituted aromatic rings, it is necessary to introduce substituents in the proper order. A group that is introduced out of order will not have the proper directing effect. Remember that in many of these reactions a mixture of ortho and para isomers may be formed.

(a)

image

(b)

image

(c)

image

(d)

image

 

General Problems

8.47 image

 

8.48 image

The ortho and para products predominate because the intermediate carbocation is more stabilized. The third resonance form drawn for ortho-para attack places the positive charge at the methyl-substituted carbon, which is a more stable tertiary carbocation.

 

8.49 Note: In the cyclic compounds, the charge can be placed on every atom in the ring, while in the linear compounds the charge can only reside on every other atom.
(a) image
(b) image

 

8.50 (a) image
(b) image

 

8.51 Resonance forms for the intermediate from attack at C1:

image

Resonance forms for the intermediate from attack at C2:

image

There are seven resonance forms for attack at C1 and six for attack at C2. Look carefully at the forms, however. In the first four resonance structures for C1 attack, the second ring is still fully aromatic. In the other three forms, however, the positive charge has been delocalized into the second ring, destroying the ring’s aromaticity. For C2 attack, only the first two resonance structures have a fully aromatic second ring. Since stabilization is lost when aromaticity is disrupted, the intermediate from C2 attack is less stable than the intermediate from C1 attack, and C1 attack is favored.

 

8.52 Both of these syntheses test your ability to carry out steps in the correct order.

(a)

image

 

8.53 Problem 8.35 shows the mechanism of the addition of HBr to 1-phenylpropene and shows how the aromatic ring stabilizes the carbocation intermediate. For the methoxyl-substituted styrene, an additional resonance form can be drawn in which the cation is stabilized by the electron-donating resonance effect of the oxygen atom. For the nitro-substituted styrene, the cation is destabilized by the electron-withdrawing effect of the nitro group.

image

Thus, the intermediate resulting from addition of HBr to the methoxyl-substituted styrene is more stable, and reaction of p-methoxystyrene is faster.

 

8.54  

image

An electron-withdrawing substituent destabilizes a positively charged intermediate (as in electrophilic aromatic substitution) but stabilizes a negatively charged intermediate. For the dissociation of a phenol, an –NO2 group stabilizes the phenoxide anion by resonance, thus lowering ΔG° and pKa. In the starred resonance form for p-nitrophenol, the negative charge has been delocalized onto the oxygens of the nitro group.

 

8.55 For the same reason described in the previous problem, a methyl group destabilizes the negatively charged intermediate, thus raising ΔG° and pKa, making this phenol less acidic.

 

8.56  

(a)

image

(b)

image

(c)

image

(d)

image

License

Icon for the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License

Solutions Manual Fundamentals of Organic Chemistry-Openstax Adaptation Copyright © by Kirsten Kramer and Cassandra Lilly is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License, except where otherwise noted.

Share This Book