5.5 Sequence Rules for Specifying Configuration

David Tully

5.5 Sequence Rules for Specifying Configuration

Structural drawings provide a visual representation of stereochemistry, but a written method for indicating the three-dimensional arrangement, or configuration, of substituents at a chirality center is also needed. The method used a set of sequence rules to rank the four groups attached to the chirality center and then looks at the handedness with which those groups are attached. Called the Cahn–Ingold–Prelog rules after the chemists who proposed them, the sequence rules are as follows:

RULE 1

Look at the four atoms directly attached to the chirality center, and rank them according to atomic number. The atom with the highest atomic number has the highest ranking (first), and the atom with the lowest atomic number (usually hydrogen) has the lowest ranking (fourth). When different isotopes of the same element are compared, such as deuterium (2H) and protium (1H), the heavier isotope ranks higher than the lighter isotope. Thus, atoms commonly found in organic compounds have the following order.

RULE 2

If a decision can’t be reached by ranking the first atoms in the substituent, look at the second, third, or fourth atoms away from the chirality center until the first difference is found. A −CH2CH3 substituent and a −CH3 substituent are equivalent by rule 1 because both have carbon as the first atom. By rule 2, however, ethyl ranks higher than methyl because ethyl has a carbon as its highest second atom, while methyl has only hydrogen as its second atom. Look at the following pairs of examples to see how the rule works:

RULE 3

Multiple-bonded atoms are equivalent to the same number of single-bonded atoms. For example, an aldehyde substituent (–CH═O), which has a carbon atom doubly bonded to one oxygen, is equivalent to a substituent having a carbon atom singly bonded to two oxygens:

As further examples, the following pairs are equivalent:

Having ranked the four groups attached to a chiral carbon, we describe the stereochemical configuration around the carbon by orienting the molecule so that the group with the lowest ranking (4) points directly away from us. We then look at the three remaining substituents, which now appear to radiate toward us like the spokes on a steering wheel (Figure 5.8). If a curved arrow drawn from the highest to second-highest to third-highest ranked substituent (1 → 2 → 3) is clockwise, we say that the chirality center has the R configuration (S for the Latin rectus, meaning “right”). If an arrow from 1 → 2 → 3 is counterclockwise, the chirality center has the S configuration (Latin sinister, meaning “left”). To remember these assignments, think of a car’s steering wheel when making a Right (clockwise) turn.

Figure 5.8 Assigning R and S configurations to chirality centers. When the molecule is oriented so that the lowest-ranked group (4) is toward the rear, the remaining three groups radiate toward the viewer like the spokes of a steering wheel. If the direction of travel 1 → 2 → 3 is clockwise (right turn), the center has the R configuration. If the direction of travel 1 → 2 → 3 is counterclockwise (left turn), the center is S.

Look at (−)-lactic acid in Figure 5.9 for an example of how to assign configuration. Sequence rule 1 says that −OH is ranked 1 and −H is ranked 4, but it doesn’t allow us to distinguish between −CH3 and −CO2H because both groups have carbon as their first atom. Sequence rule 2, however, says that −CO2H ranks higher than −CH3 because O (the highest second atom in −CO2H) outranks H (the highest second atom in −CH3). Now, turn the molecule so that the fourth-ranked group (−H) is oriented toward the rear, away from the observer.

Since a curved arrow from 1 (−OH) to 2 (−CO2H) to 3 (−CH3) is clockwise (right turn of the steering wheel), (−)-lactic acid has the R configuration. Applying the same procedure to (+)- lactic acid leads to the opposite assignment.

Figure 5.9Assigning configuration to (a) (R)-(−)-lactic acid and (b) (S)-(+)-lactic acid.

Further examples are provided by naturally occurring (−)-glyceraldehyde and (+)-alanine, which both have the S configuration as shown in Figure 5.10. Note that the sign of optical rotation, (+) or (−), is not related to the R,S designation. (S)-Glyceraldehyde happens to be levorotatory (−), and (S)-alanine happens to be dextrorotatory (+). There is no simple correlation between R,S configuration and direction or magnitude of optical rotation.

Figure 5.10Assigning configuration to (a) (−)-glyceraldehyde. (b) (+)-alanine. Both happen to have the S configuration, although one is levorotatory and the other is dextrorotatory.

One additional point needs to be mentioned—the matter of absolute configuration. How do we know that the assignments of R and S configuration are correct in an absolute sense, rather than a relative, sense? Since there is no correlation between the R,S configuration and the direction or magnitude of optical rotation, how do we know that the R configuration belongs to the levorotatory enantiomer of lactic acid? This difficult question was finally solved in 1951, when an X-ray diffraction method was found for determining the absolute spatial arrangement of atoms in a molecule. Based on those results, we can say with certainty that the R,S conventions are correct.

Worked Example 5.3Assigning Configuration to Chirality CentersOrient each of the following drawings so that the lowest-ranked group is toward the rear, and then assign R or S configuration to each:
StrategyIt takes practice to be able to visualize and orient a chirality center in three dimensions. You might start by indicating where the observer must be located—180° opposite the lowest-ranked group. Then imagine yourself in the position of the observer, and redraw what you would see.SolutionIn (a), you would be located in front of the page toward the top right of the molecule, and you would see group 2 to your left, group 3 to your right, and group 1 below you. This corresponds to an R configuration.

In (b), you would be located behind the page toward the top left of the molecule from your point of view, and you would see group 3 to your left, group 1 to your right, and group 2 below you. This also corresponds to an R configuration.

Worked Example 5.4Drawing the Three-Dimensional Structure of a Specific EnantiomerDraw a tetrahedral representation of (R)-2-chlorobutane.StrategyBegin by ranking the four substituents bonded to the chirality center: (1) −Cl, (2) −CH2CH3,(3) −CH3, (4) −H. To draw a tetrahedral representation of the molecule, orient the lowest- ranked group (−H) away from you and imagine that the other three groups are coming out of the page toward you. Then, place the remaining three substituents such that the direction of travel 1 → 2 → 3 is clockwise (right turn), and tilt the molecule toward you to bring the rear hydrogen into view. Using molecular models is a real help in working problems of this sort.Solution